Eric Tobia's Blog - Volta

Using Volta from the Command Line

Your DisplayName here! — Thu, 03 Jan 2008 16:03:09 GMT

While it’s unlikely that you would ever want to invoke the Volta compiler directly, using it does provide some insight into how Volta works.

Let’s say that you have an existing assembly named BoringObjects.dll. BoringObjects.dll contains one class named Person.

To do a Volta conversion of this assembly from MSIL to JavaScript execute the following command from the console window. NOTE: you will need "C:\Program Files\Microsoft Live Labs Volta" in your path.

> volta BoringObjects.dll /out:JSOutput

The only argument of interest is /out:JSOutput. This is the directory that the Volta compiler will write the JavaScript files to.

If we look under our specified output directory we notice that Volta has created a directory that corresponds to the assembly name. Under that directory there are three items:

[Types] (directory)
assembly.js
typeMapping.js

Under the Types directory there is one file "tA.js" which corresponds to the lone Person class in our original assembly. If you use /d (debug) option the file will be named "type_0__Person.js" and the JavaScript code will be nicely formatted.

It’s interesting to note that this same structure is seen in "C:\Program Files\Microsoft Live Labs Volta\Cache". In that directory you will find that some core .NET assemblies and the Volta libraries have been converted to JavaScript. This step is apparently part of the installation process.

The Three “R”s of Volta

Your DisplayName here! — Sat, 15 Dec 2007 02:13:11 GMT

A prevalent theme in the Volta documentation is the concept of the three “R”s. These three principles are at the heart of what Volta attempts to provide for developers. They are retargeting, remodulating, and refactoring.

Retargeting

To me this is the coolest aspect of Volta and the feature that makes it a very interesting technology. At its core Volta is a compiler or more accurately a recompiler. Instead of recompiling the source code Volta uses a technique called MSIL rewriting. This is what enables the developer to write client-side browser code in C#. Since all CLR languages compile to MSIL, Volta can use that as the common denominator. Volta is capable of MSIL to MSIL, and MSIL to JavaScript conversion.

Remodulating

Another goal of the Volta toolset is seamless cross-browser support. As the documentation states:

Volta hides as many browser-specific differences as possible, but still allows developers to leverage the unique capabilities of particular browsers. Instead of targeting solely the intersection of browser capabilities, Volta targets the entire union, but makes the intersection browser-agnostic. This is browser remodulating.

Remodulating also deals with the debugging experience. Regardless of the browser platform developers will be stepping through their application code within Visual Studio. That's assuming of course that your target is either IE or FireFox which are the only browsers supported in the current release.

Refactoring

Volta refactoring is about enabling developers to create their applications while deferring decisions about what tier a particular component will run in. In my opinion this will be the most controversial feature of the toolset. Larry O’Brien has some reservations about it:

This sounds like a bad idea to me. You can't refactor away the difference between an in-memory method call and an Internet message: one happens in nanoseconds and the other in milliseconds

I have some questions of my own about this. The docs claim that:

During development, all code runs in the client for ease of testing and debugging.

What are the implications of this? Not every .NET class is meant to run in a browser context. Does Volta offer any automatic guidance with regard to this? The notion of clicking a “Split Tiers” check box and decorating a class with a [RunAtOrigin] does seem implicitly powerful, I’m just curious to know where the model breaks down. I will try to answer these questions and others as I dig deeper into the framework.

Volta

Your DisplayName here! — Thu, 06 Dec 2007 02:55:23 GMT

It's kind of ironic. This morning I was seriously considering taking a look at the Google Web Toolkit. This is despite the fact that GWT is targeted at Java developers, which I am not. It's just that GWT seems like such a useful idea - I wanted to play with it a bit.

Luckily Microsoft has, apparently, decided to put out a framework that allows developers to build rich internet applications without having to do a ton of JavaScript coding.

It's called Volta and at first glance it seems pretty cool.

When I was doing a lot of work with ASP.NET AJAX last year, the idea of coding in a more productive language and environment than JavaScript kept coming up again and again. There was Script# at the time, but I didn't get a chance to look into it as much as I would have liked.

This certainly seems like a great development. Maybe this even brings .NET developers one step closer to what Joel Spolsky described a few month ago.

Now…on to the samples, tutorials, and docs!